Markets are built for stories that resolve quickly. Mines are not.
A lithium deposit takes 10 or 15 years to travel from a geologist’s map to a truck full of battery-grade powder, and the stock attached to it has to survive every mood swing in between. Investors who bought the electric-vehicle boom in 2021 learned that the hard way.
Battery-grade lithium carbonate averaged $71,100 per metric ton in 2022, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. Two years later that average had collapsed to $14,000.
Projects were shelved, price targets were cut, and an entire category of stock turned into a punchline. That is roughly where American lithium sat at the start of this summer, written off by most of the people paid to have an opinion on it.
Then one of the largest banks on Wall Street looked at the same wreckage everyone else had spent August marking down, and decided the pack had it backwards.
Why Thacker Pass matters to U.S. lithium supply
Lithium Americas (LAC) is a Vancouver-based developer with essentially one asset that counts. Thacker Pass, in Humboldt County, Nev., is described by the company as the largest known measured lithium resource and reserve in the world.
More Wall Street:
- SpaceX investors get bold Wall Street price target for 2027 year-end
- Anthropic sends clear message to Wall Street ahead of IPO
- Bank of America’s unique take on Apple stock as Ternus takes reins
The project is a joint venture. Lithium Americas holds 62% and manages construction, while General Motors (GM) holds 38% after a $625 million investment that also bought it rights to the entire first phase of production.
Phase 1 targets 40,000 metric tons a year of battery-quality lithium carbonate, according to Lithium Americas. Across all phases the plan runs to 160,000 metric tons.
To understand why Washington cares, look at what the country actually produces. Commercial-scale U.S. lithium production came from a single continental brine operation in Nevada, and the government does not even publish the volume, because “domestic production data were withheld to avoid disclosing company proprietary data,” per the USGS.
What struck me when I went through that data sheet was not the withheld production line. It was the employment line. Total U.S. lithium mine and mill employment was listed at 70 people.
Related: JP Morgan CEO has blunt inflation message
Seventy. That is the entire domestic workforce standing between American battery makers and a supply chain that runs through someone else’s country.
The federal government has since taken a direct position. The Department of Energy holds a 5% equity stake in Lithium Americas and a separate 5% economic stake in the Thacker Pass venture, both through warrants exercisable at one cent, as part of a restructured $2.26 billion loan, PBS News reported. The deal advanced a first draw of $435 million and deferred $182 million of debt service.
What JPMorgan sees in Lithium Americas stock now
On Sept. 9, JPMorgan upgraded Lithium Americas from neutral to overweight and set a price target of $6.00, or C$8.00, according to Investing.com. Against a stock trading near $3, that implies roughly 100% upside.
The mechanism is not a construction surprise. It is a commodity assumption. A refresh of the bank’s lithium price deck lifted long-term earnings estimates from 2029 onward, which lifted net asset value, which lifted the target.
JPMorgan expects the market to run in deficit through the end of the decade as Western greenfield supply stays sidelined. The bank also cited “increasing confidence in Thacker Pass execution,” pointing to detailed engineering more than 95% complete and procurement more than 80% complete.
Here is the price context that actually drives the model:
- Battery-grade lithium carbonate averaged $71,100 per metric ton in 2022 and $14,000 in 2024, according to the U.S. Geological Survey.
- Lithium carbonate equivalent has held above $20 per kilogram since mid-February and stood at $22.30 at the time of the upgrade, according to Investing.com.
- Batteries accounted for 87% of global lithium end use, according to the USGS.
- U.S. net import reliance ran above 50% of apparent consumption, according to the USGS.
- Chile and Argentina together supplied 97% of U.S. lithium imports from 2020 through 2023, according to the USGS.
I ran the current quote against that USGS series, and the gap is the whole argument. At $22.30 per kilogram, lithium sits about 59% above the 2024 annual average and still roughly 69% below the 2022 peak.
JPMorgan is underwriting the recovery. The rest of the Street is underwriting the hangover.
Where JPMorgan splits from the rest of the Street
August was brutal for this name. BMO Capital cut its target to $4 on Aug. 14, Deutsche Bank cut to $4.20 on Aug. 16, and TD Securities cut to $4.50 on Aug. 17, each keeping a neutral-equivalent rating. Goldman Sachs initiated coverage at neutral with a $4.50 target.
That makes JPMorgan’s $6 the high mark on the Street by about a third, and 50% above BMO’s number. This is not a bank nudging a target. It is a bank standing on the opposite side of the table from four of its peers, and that is far more interesting than the upgrade itself.
Two details most of the coverage skipped. First, the $6 is a December 2027 target, not a 12-month one, so the implied 100% return is stretched across more than two years of construction risk.
Second, the company filed in August to register 72.55 million shares for selling holders. Against roughly 363 million shares outstanding, that is a meaningful supply overhang sitting on top of any rally. Broader Wall Street forecasts have not been kind to pre-revenue miners either.
What the analyst split means for lithium investors
The honest read is that nobody on the Street is arguing about the rock. Thacker Pass is real, it is being built, and Washington owns a piece of it.
The argument is about the price of lithium in 2029 and whether a company with no revenue can get there without diluting the people who are waiting. Demand assumptions have not been steady either, as U.S. automakers keep changing their EV plans, and imported equipment costs have moved with tariff policy.
For anyone holding this stock, the practical takeaway is to stop treating analyst targets as forecasts and start reading their dates. A $6 target for December 2027 and a $4 target for next year are not contradictory. They are answers to two different questions.
The question worth watching is not whether JPMorgan is right. It is whether Thacker Pass ships its first commercial ton before the money runs out, because the deficit JPMorgan is betting on only pays this company if the plant is running when it arrives.
